Quick answer: your guitar is fine; the recording isn’t at A4 = 440 Hz. Hold a chromatic tuner up to a long note in the song to see how many cents off it is, then either set your tuner’s reference to match (for example 442 Hz for +8 cents) and retune, or keep your guitar at 440 and shift the recording to meet you.
Why recordings drift off standard tuning
A recording can be perfectly in tune with itself and still clash with a guitar tuned to 440 Hz. The usual reasons:
- Speed changes. Tape that ran slightly fast or slow, or a song sped up in mastering, moves the pitch with it. Just 1% faster raises everything about 17 cents.
- A different reference. Bands tuned to a studio piano, to each other, or to 442, 444 or 432 Hz. (Here’s what 432 Hz vs 440 Hz actually changes.)
- Video and upload processing. Old film and some video conversions shift pitch slightly, which is why a song on YouTube can sound off while the CD version doesn’t.
- Deliberate detuning. Half step down (E♭) and lower tunings are common in rock and metal. That’s a whole fret, not a few cents, so it needs a different fix: see how to tune a guitar half step down.
Step 1: Measure how far off the recording is
- Open our free online tuner and choose Chromatic.
- Play the song on a speaker and hold the mic near it during a single sustained note: a held bass note, the last note of the song, or a long sung note. Busy, full-band moments confuse any tuner.
- Read the cents. Take two or three notes and average them.
| Tuner reads | What it means | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Within ±5 cents | The recording is standard; check your own tuning and intonation | Retune your guitar |
| 5 to 50 cents off | Slightly off A440 | Step 2 or Step 3 below |
| About 100 cents flat | Half step down (E♭) | Tune down a semitone, or raise the song one semitone |
| About 200 cents flat | Whole step down (D) | Tune down a whole step, or raise the song two semitones |
Step 2 (free): Retune your guitar to the recording
Set the tuner’s Reference A4 to the recording’s pitch, then tune every string as normal. The reference is 440 × 2^(cents ÷ 1200), so you don’t need to guess:
| Recording is | Set reference A4 to |
|---|---|
| 40 cents flat | 430 Hz |
| 30 cents flat | 432 Hz |
| 20 cents flat | 435 Hz |
| 10 cents flat | 437.5 Hz |
| 10 cents sharp | 442.5 Hz |
| 20 cents sharp | 445 Hz |
| 30 cents sharp | 448 Hz |
| 40 cents sharp | 450 Hz |
The browser tuner accepts 415 to 466 Hz; the Pitchius app’s free tuner accepts 430 to 450 Hz. No tuner handy? Tune by ear: pause on a clear low note, match your low E (or whichever string fits) to it, then tune the rest from that string with the usual 5th-fret method (step by step in how to tune a guitar by ear).
The catch: you’re now out of tune with every other song, your band and any keyboard. For one practice session that’s fine. For a set list it means retuning between songs, which is where the next option helps.
Step 3: Keep your guitar at 440 and shift the recording
Instead of moving six strings, move the song. A pitch shifter that changes key without changing speed can nudge the recording by the exact number of cents you measured, so it lines up with your standard-tuned guitar.
In Pitchius:
- Add the song from Files, a voice memo, a video in Photos, or a purchased song stored on your iPhone. Streaming Apple Music and Spotify songs are copy-protected, so no app can open them; use a file you own.
- If the recording was about 100 cents flat, raise the key +1 semitone (or +2 for whole step down). Your first 3 songs get every free feature, including key and tempo.
- For a smaller offset, use Fine tune (Pro, ±50 cents) in the opposite direction to what you measured: if the song was 20 cents sharp, set −20 cents.
- Check with the tuner again, or just play along. Pitchius remembers the setting for that song.
You can also slow a fast passage down without changing the corrected pitch; see how to slow down a song without changing the pitch.
Which should you use?
| Situation | Best fix |
|---|---|
| One song, practising alone | Retune your guitar to the recording (free) |
| Learning several songs in a row | Shift each recording to 440 so you never retune |
| Recording is a half step or whole step down | Tune down, or raise the song 1–2 semitones |
| Playing with a band or keyboard | Keep the guitar at 440 and shift the recording |
| Readings jump around | Measure a quieter, single held note; full mixes mislead tuners |
If the recording measures within 5 cents and still sounds wrong, the problem is likely your guitar’s intonation (fretted notes going sharp higher up the neck) rather than the song. Tune the open strings, then compare the 12th fret on the tuner: if it reads sharp or flat, the guitar needs an intonation setup.